Cities and...

Why are the cities classified with those titles? From what I've seen each title represents criticism of society and what humanity has become.

The book criticizes how people are never satisfied with what they have, so they either pretend they have it or "the traveler recognizes the little that is his, discovering the much he has not had and will never have " (29).  People are never happy. They may have all the money in the world or all they always desired but they still want more. It happens in all aspects of life, not only with material belongings but with literally genetic belongings. It’s sad to see how unthankful people are and how the world has become a place where desire goes beyond necessity. 

Cities and desires:

"In every age someone, looking at Fedora as it was, imagined a way of making it the ideal city.." (32) People are not pleased with what they have, most people are seeking their utopia, but does it exist?  Cities and desires remind me of the song imagine by John Lenon. People always desire to find a perfect world. The ideal world varies according to the perceptive of what the ideal life is for people. Unfortunately we have grown with the mentality that perfection is tangible and achievable when in reality it is not. We think perfection is attainable and therefore become lost in dreams that reflect our deepest desires.

Cities and memories:

I think the cities in these chapters are indirectly criticizing how people live in regrets. People are always thinking about the possible outcomes of their actions and once they make one decision they go back to the past and try to decipher what could have happened if they had gone the other way. People have a plethora of images from the past. We are constantly trying to recreate those images to keep the memory vivid. The truth is that our memory distorts the reality and may keep us with remorse.

Trading Cities:

The purpose of these cities in the book is to evaluate how society has become so superficial. Communications between people has become shallow. People are so concerned about their past they stop living their present and forget about their future. They leave people and thing from their present behind and get lost in their memory. Most of our society today is so self centered that they only think about themselves and they don't "trade" anything useful the worlds traded are plain and meaningless.

Cities and Signs:

“Each man bears in his mind a city made only of differences, a city without figures, without form, and the individual cities fill it up.” (34) Each city has different signs and characteristics that make it unique, but people always want what the others have. The image of perfection comes from trends. What seems perfect today will definitely not be perfect tomorrow or might have not been perfect in the past. The cities in Cities and Signs are trying to show how people create their destiny. They create and mold their past and their present according to what they want.

Thin Cities:

“Years and changes continue to give their form to desires, and those in which desires either erase the city or are erased by it.” (35) People are doomed to temptation. Changes come with time and with both discontent and contentment. Unhappiness reins the world because no one is satisfied with what they have. People always want more. What thin cities talk about or criticize is how people always want what their “neighbor has”, people are in a way in scaffolds or in “platforms and balconies placed on stilts at various heights, crossing one another” (35) If they take the wrong step they fall, and people are so scared of falling that they dream about change but never take the risk to make it happen. Thin Cities show the fear and the desire people have. Which weighs more?

“With cities, it is as with dreams: everything imaginable can be dreamed, but even the most unexpected dream is rebus that conceals a desire or, its reverse, a fear” (44)